Diversification is a foundational principle in investing. It’s often said, “Don’t put all your eggs in one basket,” and for good reason—spreading your investments across different assets helps manage risk and mitigate potential losses. But what happens when diversification goes too far? Over-diversification can dilute your returns and create unnecessary complexity in your portfolio, potentially doing more harm than good.
This article explores the concept of over-diversification, its potential downsides, and actionable steps to ensure your portfolio remains strategically balanced. If you’ve ever wondered whether your portfolio might be trying to do too much, read on for clarity and guidance.
The Concept of Over-Diversification
Before understanding the pitfalls, it’s important to grasp what over-diversification entails. Diversification involves spreading investments across asset classes (e.g., stocks, bonds, real estate) and within asset categories (e.g., stocks from different industries or regions). Its purpose is to reduce risk by avoiding reliance on any single asset.
Over-diversification, however, occurs when a portfolio contains too many investments to the extent that any potential benefits are neutralised. It typically happens in two forms:
- Holding excessively similar investments (e.g., multiple investments in funds tracking the same index).
- Owning too many assets across too many categories, creating inefficiency and redundancy: While diversification maintains balance, over-diversification dillutes returns and introduces unnecessary confusion.
When Does Diversification Become Over-Diversification?
There’s no perfect number of investments for every portfolio. Factors such as your financial goals, investment strategy, and risk tolerance all determine the ideal level of diversification. However, owning 50 or more stocks or multiple funds that overlap in scope is often a sign you might be over-diversifying.
The Downsides of Over-Diversification
While diversification can protect your portfolio against risk, over-diversification often leads to diminishing returns. Below are the key downsides associated with this issue.
- Returns May Be Watered Down: When you own too many investments, the performance of a few standout assets may have a minimal impact on your overall returns. If 90% of your portfolio delivers averagely, the excellent performance of the remaining 10% will likely be absorbed by the mediocrity.
- Portfolio Complexity: Managing a bloated portfolio requires significant time and effort. Tracking performance, rebalancing, and monitoring market conditions become exponentially more difficult as you add more assets. For an everyday investor, this complexity can lead to decision fatigue and missed opportunities.
- Higher Fees and Costs: Each investment you own—whether it’s a share, ETF, or mutual fund—comes with associated fees. Over-diversification often means holding several funds with overlapping holdings, leading to unnecessary duplication in management fees and transaction costs.
- Limited Outperformance Potential: By investing in too many assets, your chances of significantly outperforming the broader market diminish. This is because an overly diversified portfolio often mirrors the performance of the market itself. Passive strategies like index funds are great for replicating the market but including excessive overlapping funds dilutes the ability to focus on high-potential investments.
How to Strike the Right Balance
Finding the right level of diversification is key to building a portfolio that effectively manages risk while maximising returns. Here’s how you can avoid the pitfalls of over-diversification:
- Focus on Quality Over Quantity: Rather than owning a large number of investments, focus on high-quality assets that align with your goals and risk tolerance. A concentrated portfolio of well-researched investments often performs better than a vast array of uncoordinated assets.
- Understand Your Investment Objectives: Your goals should dictate your diversification strategy. Are you saving for retirement decades away? You may need a broader range of growth-oriented assets. Or are you nearing retirement and aiming for stability? A tighter focus on income-generating investments may be more appropriate.
- Reduce Overlapping Investments: Check for duplication across your portfolio, particularly in mutual funds or ETFs. Ensure the funds you own offer unique exposures and don’t overlap unnecessarily.
- Regular Portfolio Reviews: Schedule regular reviews to evaluate your portfolio’s performance, fees, and overall strategy. A once-a-year reassessment, at a minimum, can prevent your portfolio from becoming cluttered.
- Work with a Financial Adviser: A professional who understands your financial situation can help you streamline your portfolio without compromising on diversification. Engaging an adviser ensures your investments maintain balance while reflecting your broader goals.
Diversification vs. Over-Diversification—Striking the Right Note
Achieving the optimal level of diversification is an ongoing process rather than a one-time decision. The goal is not to add investments endlessly but to create a portfolio that is both balanced and efficient. Here’s how to assess whether your diversification efforts are on the right track:
- Balanced Risk: Does each asset class offer complementary benefits without over-concentrating in any one area?
- Intentional Inclusion: Is each holding in your portfolio strategically chosen for its unique benefits?
- Streamlined Approach: Can you manage and monitor your portfolio without feeling overwhelmed?
Final Thoughts
Diversification is undoubtedly important, but too much of it can hinder your financial progress. By taking a balanced approach, focusing on quality investments, and regularly reviewing your portfolio, you can avoid the trap of over-diversification. Remember, a streamlined and strategic portfolio often delivers stronger long-term results than an unnecessarily complex one.
If you would like to improve your current investment strategies or are looking to start your investment journey, click here to organise a complimentary 20-minute phone call with an EPG Wealth adviser.